A federal judge in Manhattan ruled yesterday that the Helping Families Save Their Homes Act of 2009 did not exempt Countrywide from investor lawsuits. Countrywide had argued that the federal legislation automatically voided its pledge to buy back loans from investors if those loans were modified for troubled borrowers. The Helping Families Save Their Homes Act of 2009 was meant to help encourage servicing companies to modify loans, in part by providing some protection under liability arising from loan changes.
However, many of the mortgages owned by Countrywide (which has since been purchased by Bank of America), are owned by investors. The investors receive interests and principal payments from borrowers over the life of the loans. When the loans are modified, these payments are typically reduced. The investors are arguing that when Countrywide and Bank of America agreed to modify the loans, they breached their contract with the investors.
The ruling in the case said that the legislation did not prevent Countrywide’s investors from trying to enforce their rights under the mortgage servicing contracts. It would be up to the investors to prove that Countrywide’s pooling and servicing agreement requires it to repurchase the loans the bank modifies. The case would be in state court, outside of federal jurisdiction. Countrywide wanted the case to take place in federal court, due to the law being a federal law.
This case has some interesting implications. Right now, the Obama Administration has made it their priority to modify mortgages for borrowers, attempting to help the over 13% of homeowners who are currently delinquent on their mortgages. However, this case shows that even if the servicing companies and lenders agree, other parties, such as investors and hedge funds, may object. Certaintly there are bound to be losers from the housing bust and subprime mortgage crisis- the question is who will bear the brunt of the blow. As individuals argue in their self interest, it appears dangerously likely that the good of the collective whole will suffer.